Will Peyton Manning be the best ever if he wins the Superbowl with the Broncos

**bobby heenan** · 09-09-13, 12:15 PM

Originally posted by ThaTopMoron

Vinny, Defense and all of the coaching staff = MVP of Pats 2001 to 2004

Tom has been a BETTER qb year by year AFTER those years...and what does he have to show for it? 0-2 in the Super Bowl. Defense couldn't get the late game stops to help him win more SB's with 14 and 17 points respectively.

Point proven.

thats a bit unfair...brady still had a great game against carolina....350 with 3 tds...the pats actually had control of that game and the defense let them down to which brady had to respond(lost two guys in the secondary in the 2nd half).....for those of us who remember that game well

against philly he did his thing too....him and branch took what was there and they took what was there.....I can honestly say the rams superbowl he was a limit mistakes/game manager....but at that point that is what he was....the guy can play.....the first giants superbowl he was injured...whether people want to admit it or not...the guy was in a boot leading up to that superbowl...he of course brushed it off and wasnt going to miss it for the world....the giants did their thing with a little bit of luck.....if gronk was healthy things might have been different in the second one....but it didnt work out....no shame....this guy is two(or three) plays away,literally, from being a 5 time superbowl champ....

**odog11** · 09-09-13, 01:09 PM

Winning percentages:

Regular season:
Brady 77.8%
Manning 68.9%

Playoffs:
Brady 70.8%
Manning 45%

As noted Manning has a losing record in the playoffs.

Brady has better winning percentage in playoffs than
Manning does in regular season.

**dilaudid8** · 09-09-13, 04:56 PM

you give me brady not even close my brother. Montana now your talking

**detroitlionsfan** · 09-09-13, 05:00 PM

broncos have to come out of the afc this yr

patriots / ravens down yrs

whos gonna beat them colts/texans ??? the chiefs ??????????????

gonna be broncos vs 49ers/seahawks/redskins

**lakerboy** · 09-09-13, 05:30 PM

He lost a superbowl. End of thread.

**KiDBaZkiT** · 09-09-13, 05:58 PM

So what Brady lost two. With the team and coach Manning had he had NO business even getting to that Superbowl.

**lakerboy** · 09-09-13, 06:08 PM

Originally posted by KiDBaZkiT

So what Brady lost two. With the team and coach Manning had he had NO business even getting to that Superbowl.

yet they were favored in the superbowl and the great manning threw the pick 6 that sealed there fate. As for brady I never said he was the best.

The best qb all time was montana. It isn't even up for debate.

**slacker00** · 09-09-13, 07:15 PM

Peyton isn't even the best QB in his own locker room, Elway was 14-8 in the playoffs.

**C-Gold** · 09-09-13, 08:46 PM

2 black radio hosts were just dogging Peyton Manning over and over and over again before the Thursday night game.

He's not that good.
Defenses figured him out
He's only won 1 ring
He's Dan Marino with a ring.
He's always had great talent around him!
He's always had good running backs like Edge and Joe Addai and now he has a beast in Monte Ball
He never took a pay cut like Tom Brady did to bring in more talent

These same black idiots talk about about how great the latest crop of black QBs are like they do every 3-4 years. They thought Jason Campbell was the truth. Jason F'in Campbell. Then they made excuses for him for 5 years. Now Peyton Manning isn't that good because he's always had superstar running backs like Joe Addai LOL.

**Deol** · 09-09-13, 09:05 PM

Originally posted by lakerboy

The best qb all time was montana. It isn't even up for debate.

Rarely agree with you, but yah Montana or Brady will go down as best ever IMO.

**slacker00** · 09-09-13, 10:42 PM

Originally posted by C-Gold

2 black radio hosts were just dogging Peyton Manning over and over and over again before the Thursday night game.

He's not that good.
Defenses figured him out
He's only won 1 ring
He's Dan Marino with a ring.
He's always had great talent around him!
He's always had good running backs like Edge and Joe Addai and now he has a beast in Monte Ball
He never took a pay cut like Tom Brady did to bring in more talent

These same black idiots talk about about how great the latest crop of black QBs are like they do every 3-4 years. They thought Jason Campbell was the truth. Jason F'in Campbell. Then they made excuses for him for 5 years. Now Peyton Manning isn't that good because he's always had superstar running backs like Joe Addai LOL.

They thought Jason Campbell better than Peyton? Who were you listening to, Stephen A. Smith?

**ebelisle22** · 09-09-13, 10:45 PM

no because denver will never win the super bowl

**greenhippo** · 09-09-13, 10:55 PM

Why is the comparison Brady and Manning anyway? Bradshaw 4-0 Superbowl, Montana 4-0. Hell the comparison should be more Manning vs Aikman right now although Aikman is 3-0 in SBs.

**2daBank** · 09-10-13, 02:02 AM

Originally posted by greenhippo

Why is the comparison Brady and Manning anyway? Bradshaw 4-0 Superbowl, Montana 4-0. Hell the comparison should be more Manning vs Aikman right now although Aikman is 3-0 in SBs.

for me it montana all day..bradshaw cmon that dude wasnt a great qb by any means, even in todays nfl he couldnt put up numbers like these cats..

**2daBank** · 09-10-13, 02:02 AM

hgh a hell of a drug!

**greenhippo** · 09-10-13, 02:08 AM

Numbers only get you so much, wins and rings is what counts at the end of the season. Brees' numbers last year didn't exactly win him much.

**2daBank** · 09-10-13, 02:10 AM

Originally posted by greenhippo

Numbers only get you so much, wins and rings is what counts at the end of the season. Brees' numbers last year didn't exactly win him much.

yea but bradshaw had arguably the best defense of all time, he wasnt exactly winning those rings as it was a different gm back then the qb didnt have to win it.

**RonPaul2008** · 09-10-13, 02:10 AM

The person who started this thread must be on crack.

Here is a few better off the top of my head from the last 3 decades:

1) Joe Montana
2) Steve Young
3) Tom Brady
4) Troy Aikman
5) John Elway

**2daBank** · 09-10-13, 02:12 AM

Originally posted by RonPaul2008

The person who started this thread must be on crack.

naw just the biggest bronco homer on sbr..

**slacker00** · 09-11-13, 08:19 AM

Originally posted by RonPaul2008

The person who started this thread must be on crack.

Here is a few better off the top of my head from the last 3 decades:

1) Joe Montana
2) Steve Young
3) Tom Brady
4) Troy Aikman
5) John Elway

I've never been a Young fan, if anything he left rings on the table... 1.Montana 2.Brady 3.Unitas 4.Elway 5.Favre

**frostno98** · 09-29-13, 06:29 PM

This guy will shatter all NFL regular season passing record this year.

**eidolon** · 10-04-13, 06:22 PM

I will take Peyton manning for any single regular season game.
I will take Joe Montana for every super bowl.