[rocky16]

Originally <a href='http://www.sportsbookreview.com/forum/showthread.php?p=22916337'>posted</a> on 11/03/2014:

you can't start going 'fluke' this or 'fluke' that..

he played a 'Manning' in those and Brady missed wide-open receivers. Eli did not.

Brady did not inspire his teammates to make insane catches that were extremely well covered.
and ELI did.

Eli hit his guys when it mattered most. Late in the 4th Qtr, on game winning Touchdown drives.

Brady does not have Superbowl nerves.

Brady does not have Superbowl nerves that's why he led his team on two game winning drives against Carolina and as 14 point dog against rams when fatass john Madden said he should've knelt and went to OT. In loss to giants he led his team on a would be game winning TD drive before the fluke helmet catch. He has 11 TDs and 2 picks in superbowls for a QB rating of 94. He's 4th all time in TD passes. 5th all time in yards passed. 3rd all time in wins. 1st in playoff wins. He has the stats he has the wins. He's the very definition of a winner.

Montana being 4-0 in superbowls is a weak argument. In the NFC championship game before his 1st SB win he threw 3 picks against Dallas. Only had 157 yards passing in the SB that season. In the 2nd SB run he had 3 TDs and 3 picks prior to the SB. His defense gave up 3 points in those games. They carried him the the SB. The next 3 seasons his teams were one and done in the playoffs.Montana played lime crap in those games. His teams scored 3 fgs in those games. Montana had 0 TDs and 4 picks and a 50 rating in those games. He was even pulled against an 8-7 vikings team he was so bad. The last two SB runs he played amazing but people forget he wasn't this unbeatable winner he's made out to be.

Not to discredit Montana but he had his flaws. Every QB has flaws. Brady is no exception but he's one of the greatest QBs of all time and his career is not complete. He's most certainly better that Manning and comes up bigger when it counts the most. That can't be debated.