Originally posted on 12/23/2012:

Regardless of the outcome I like this thread. Honestly I think sbrjohn will be interested in the results as well. Every successful business needs feedback. Now we get to grade the grader. Well done, elementer.

I just hope people will give an honest grade as opposed to using this as part of their witch hunt against SBR or try to skew the results simply to funny or cute.

edit: with that said, I gave them a D. Mainly because you specifically used the word credibility. Had you asked how I felt they have graded books in the past and even currently, I would have given them a B, because I do feel they get it right most of the time.

however, how can there be any credibility when SBR takes money from these affiliate books each month and then proceeds to also be the one to rate them. And to muddy the waters even further, they accept monies from players to go "pro". And then also arbitrate between the two sides, both of whom they've now accepted money from.

sorry but there can't be any credibility in that system.