Originally posted on 11/25/2012:

Quote Originally Posted by princecharles View Post
Bill,
What SHOULD the OP have done? If you heard this complete story over a beer at a bar, and were 'blindfolded' as to which book it was, are telling us you would reply to this man in the bar with the essence of your afore posted position?
perhaps that should be the standard practice here in the future.

explain the issue, but don't say what book it was. then when bill says his 2 cents, reveal which book was the culprit.