Eli his averaging 35 more yards per game, while his wrs have also been beat up this yr, with his main weapon being an undrafted free agent... His best RB has also been down most of the year.. Point being though... yes, their numbers are similar, both have had great statistical years.. but, you gotta give the edge to Eli as right now they are the favorite to win the division and he has a ring on his finger. They in my mind are very close, but I think Eli has the step bc his proven ability to win big games. I still say top five are:

Top 5-
Rodgers
Brady
Peyton
Brees
Roth

6. Rivers (even though hes had a down yr)
7. 8. 9. Romo, Eli, Vick (all interchangeable depending on personal preference... i know Im a homer having Vick there, but when fully healthy, which is rare, he is def up with these guys)