Originally Posted by
Roadtrip635
Eli was never a consistently good QB, he got hot and a bit lucky at the right time on both those SB runs. Compared to other QBs during similar years Rivers, Romo and Philips, Eli was noticeably worse. OB rating 94.8, 97.1, 94.8 Eli-83.8 Eli's completion % is at least 5% lower than all three. Eli has lead the league in INTs thrown 3 different times, his worst was 27 in one season, that's really bad. Eli's INT rate is significantly higher than all three. Phillips and Eli each have 334 TDs, but Eli has thrown 60 more picks.
If Eli makes the HOF, it's because he was in the right place at the right time, he was an above average QB, but not one of the greats.