[thehoorse]

NFL Career Playoffs Passer Rating Leaders

Rank	Player (age), + - HOFer, Bold - Active	Rate	Years	Teams
1.	Bart Starr+	104.8	1956-1971	gnb
2.	Drew Brees (33)	103.9	2001-2012	2TM
3.	Aaron Rodgers (29)	103.6	2005-2012	gnb
4.	Kurt Warner	102.8	1998-2009	2TM
5.	Joe Montana+	95.6	1979-1994	2TM
6.	Mark Sanchez (26)	94.3	2009-2012	nyj
7.	Ken Anderson	93.5	1971-1986	cin
8.	Joe Theismann	91.4	1974-1985	was
9.	Eli Manning (31)	89.3	2004-2012	nyg
10.	Peyton Manning (36)	88.4	1998-2012	2TM
11.	Troy Aikman+	88.3	1989-2000	dal
12.	Tom Brady (35)	87.4	2000-2012	nwe
13.	Brett Favre	86.3	1991-2010	2TM
14.	Joe Flacco (27)	86.2	2008-2012	rav
15.	Steve Young+	85.8	1985-1999	sfo
16.	Matt Ryan (27)	85.2	2008-2012	atl
17.	Warren Moon+	84.9	1984-2000	2TM
18.	Rich Gannon	84.6	1987-2004	3TM
19.	Matt Hasselbeck (37)	84.4	1999-2012	sea
20.	Ken Stabler	84.2	1970-1984	2TM

Again, Bart Starr played versus weaker opponents due to less parity among teams. As a result, not only did he have more opportunities to make playoffs, but also perform well in them. Would be great if there was some way to adjust QB rating for disparity in competition AND changes in rules among different eras. Unfortunately no such thing exists; at least none that I know of. QB's today may face greater competition, but they also generate better stats because receivers cannot be checked all the way down the field. As a result, Greatest of all time is mostly a matter of opinion.

EDIT: Mark Sanchez is number 6 on that list

[stevenash]

I want to see if P Manning and Denver will cover 4tds this weekend against Jax.

It's not Peyton's job to win the game by x amont of points, just win. I also doubt Peyton plays the fourth quarter if Denver is up 31. Also the game could be a blowout and Denver still doesn't cover. Very foolish to bet this game on either side

[Nick Papageorgio]

Nasher, off the top of my head @New England in the playoffs. Can't site the exact year unless I look it up. Vs jets playoffs early career.

[Hot Jerry]

Wait for the playoffs

Yeah [ lol] first in and first out !! LOL

[PAULYPOKER]

Good to see that all you degens have it figured out.......


this can only add more certainty to my prediction....


The facts are, once the public majority(you degens) has a trend figured out,that said trend will do a 180 with remarkable authority........

These are the laws of degeneracy.....

[PAULYPOKER]

Fact: Denver-24 to -27.5 is the Highest point spread EVER recorded in the NFL.......


If Peyton does cover the 4TD spread...............Well, YOU KNOW!!!!!

[ZOLTAR]

Good luck winning it all with a defense ranked in the bottom 5.

Even if they did win the SB, and they won't - but if they did, how is a QB with a 12-11 playoff record the best of all time?

Right now he's 9-11 in the playoffs. He may be the best ever for the regular season but he's a playoff loser.

[frostno98]

Good luck winning it all with a defense ranked in the bottom 5.

Even if they did win the SB, and they won't - but if they did, how is a QB with a 12-11 playoff record the best of all time?

Right now he's 9-11 in the playoffs. He may be the best ever for the regular season but he's a playoff loser.

Haha 1st post just to make that comment. Who are you, Lakerboys?

[stevenash]

Good luck winning it all with a defense ranked in the bottom 5.

Even if they did win the SB, and they won't - but if they did, how is a QB with a 12-11 playoff record the best of all time?

Right now he's 9-11 in the playoffs. He may be the best ever for the regular season but he's a playoff loser.

An how many of the 11 playoff losses Manning was involved in you can without question attribute to Manning's poor play?

You watch much playoff football Lakerboy?
I don't think you do.

Last season's playoff game v. Ravens:

Is it Manning's fault Rahim Moore has a brain fart and takes a who knows what fuk angle on Jacoby Jones and gets toasted.
Is it Manning's fault Champ Bailey got abused and beat like a red headed step child by Torrey Smith?


That 17-16 loss to the Jets, Manning completed 70 percent of his passes, and had a QB rating of an ungodly 108.
What exactly was his crime there?
1 TD, no INT's on that Jet defense is huge.

The Charger loss in '08 was a fluke out there in SD
Not his fault at all again.

Manning's Colts would have won two more playoff games if VandeChoke doesn't gag on two winning FG attempts too.
Manning was solid in those two games, but you Manning haters seem to forget shank-a-saurus VandeJack cost Manning's Colts those two wins, but seem to think it was Manning attempting those two place kicks. Who do you think put the Colts in that position to win those games? Santa Claus?

Manning's teams have found a way to lose in the playoffs, with the exception of two playoff games, you can not place the blame on Manning.
This does not make Manning a playoff loser.

You are quick to point out Denveris bottom 5 defense ranked (based on points allowed) but to fail to mention that is because opposing teams have had more offense possession than any other team. Know why? Because Denver scores so much, the opposition gets the ball back more often.

You fail to mention Denver has the second best run defense.

Nice failed first post there Zoltar, whose ghost are you anyway?

[ZOLTAR]

An how many of the 11 playoff losses Manning was involved in you can without question attribute to Manning's poor play?

You watch much playoff football Lakerboy?
I don't think you do.

Who the hell is "Lakerboy?" I came here looking for trends, and noticed this thread.

Last season's playoff game v. Ravens:

He turned it over twice, but you blame the defense and don't mention either one of Manning's turnovers.

Manning's Colts would have won two more playoff games if VandeChoke doesn't gag on two winning FG attempts too.
Manning was solid in those two games, but you Manning haters seem to forget shank-a-saurus VandeJack cost Manning's Colts those two wins, but seem to think it was Manning attempting those two place kicks. Who do you think put the Colts in that position to win those games? Santa Claus?

Blaming it on the kicker is pathetic.

Manning's teams have found a way to lose in the playoffs, with the exception of two playoff games, you can not place the blame on Manning.
This does not make Manning a playoff loser.

No, but this does: his record in the playoffs is 9-11.

[stevenash]

Who the hell is "Lakerboy?" I came here looking for trends, and noticed this thread.



He turned it over twice, but you blame the defense and don't mention either one of Manning's turnovers.



Blaming it on the kicker is pathetic.



No, but this does: his record in the playoffs is 9-11.

My conclusion based on two of your posts, you are a Manning hater, and pretty much an idiot.

[ZOLTAR]

I suppose we'll see, won't we? Let's remember this thread in January!

[slacker00]

You are quick to point out Denveris bottom 5 defense ranked (based on points allowed) but to fail to mention that is because opposing teams have had more offense possession than any other team. Know why? Because Denver scores so much, the opposition gets the ball back more often.

I had to check this stat out and see for myself. As I suspected, it's just plain wrong. Denver's opponents have had a combined 64 offensive possessions which rank's Denver tied at #9 in the NFL, nothing too significant especially considering 6 teams are below that number because they have played one less game due to their bye week.

How about this stat? DEN is ranked #31 in the league allowing 6.3 yards per play.

[stevenash]

OK so I am wrong, sue me

[BettingWizard]

I love how Manning fans never bring up the fact that he had 3 touchdowns and 7 interceptions the year Addaii and the defense carried him to the title.

btw.

Pick 6 against the saints in the Super Bowl

INT in Overtime against the Ravens last year

Had 1st and goal against the Chargers the year they lost to them at home with less than 2 minutes left. He choked.

The Following year, lost to the Chargers again, only scoring 7 points in the 2nd half and Overtime. And the 7 points was on a play where the Chargers thought the play had been blown dead. All other drives in that 2nd half were 3 and outs and 1 turnover on downs where he had an incompletion on 4th and 1.


At the most his team has been an underdog 5 times of the 20 playoff games he has been on, stop with the "It's never Peyton's fault" nonsense.

[frostno98]

Manning will win another Superbowl ring within the next three years guaranteed if not this year and it still won't shut up all they haters. Keeping fading Manning idiots, especially in the playoffs this yearManning is no different than an Ace Pitcher, he does the best he possibly can to give his team a lead or in position to win. If the Saving Pitcher can't protect a lead (NFL Defense, Special teams) the choke labels goes on the them and never the Ace. Yet people like to simply nit pick what's more convenient to their argument. Peyton Manning is the only QB Bill Billicheck will go 4 and 1 on late in games even if it's in his own territory, that in it self shows you how much respect Mannings gets even from the greatest head coach in NFL history.

[the_situation]

Name me all the times Manning choked the most.
Cite games and examples please.

I hear people say how much Manning is a choker, but when pressed to name games and situations, they all do the
Ralph Kramden. hummina hummina, hummina...........

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xOjBcAcKyuA

[ThaTopMoron]

Manning will win another Superbowl ring within the next three years guaranteed if not this year and it still won't shut up all they haters. Keeping fading Manning idiots, especially in the playoffs this yearManning is no different than an Ace Pitcher, he does the best he possibly can to give his team a lead or in position to win. If the Saving Pitcher can't protect a lead (NFL Defense, Special teams) the choke labels goes on the them and never the Ace. Yet people like to simply nit pick what's more convenient to their argument. Peyton Manning is the only QB Bill Billicheck will go 4 and 1 on late in games even if it's in his own territory, that in it self shows you how much respect Mannings gets even from the greatest head coach in NFL history.

I was at that infamous "4th and 2" game in Indy in 2009... early November. Colts were down 14-31 early 4th quarter.

Some Pats fans were drunk off their ass and having a ball @ the time... and some fake Colts fans were leaving the stadium thinking the game was over. I was giving both of those crowds hell @ the time, telling both that you just wait until the Colts are within 1 score late and you're dumbass is either in your car hating yourself or you're drunk and sweating balls hoping your precious Brady doesn't lose after being up 17 in said 4th quarter.

Needless to say, about 5 seconds after Manning's TD to Wayne to go up 35-34 with 13 seconds left... all those Pat fans were hustling from their seats to the exits @ light speed

and the fake ass loyal Colt fans who left the stadium early... well... they're probably still hating themselves for what they did and I bet they have a closet full of Bronco jerseys today

[Noleafclover]

Wonder if anyone has Denver's defense's rankings before the game @ dallas

They're not that bad, but a high-scoring game will change the way they play. They go prevent earlier, and teams are obviously going to be passing and get the yardage on them there. Should be no surprise, too with the leads they're playing with, they're #4 in INTs.

As for Manning, he's the best ever because of his level of play.

[slacker00]

Should be no surprise, too with the leads they're playing with, they're #4 in INTs.

Not quite. DEN is tied for #4-#10 with 7 other teams with 7 INTs, but remember 6 teams only played 4 games.

A more accurate stat is INT%, DEN is ranked #14 with 3.3%. So, DEN is closer to average than you suggest.

[ZOLTAR]

I had to check this stat out and see for myself. As I suspected, it's just plain wrong. Denver's opponents have had a combined 64 offensive possessions which rank's Denver tied at #9 in the NFL, nothing too significant especially considering 6 teams are below that number because they have played one less game due to their bye week.

How about this stat? DEN is ranked #31 in the league allowing 6.3 yards per play.

Thanks for caring about the facts. Mr Manning Backer obviously doesn't.

[ZOLTAR]

How is a guy the "greatest" if he has a losing playoff record, had multiple turnovers in a home playoff game as a big favorite last season, and is 1-1 in Super Bowls with his interception costing them the game at end vs the Saints? The only QB more overrated than Manning was/is Brett Favre.

[ZOLTAR]

"As for Manning, he's the best ever because of his level of play."

If he's the "best ever" there are a lot of "lesser" guys I would pick.

PLAYOFF RECORDS:

Joe Flacco: 9-4, 1-0 in SB
Peyton Maning: 9-11, 1-1 in SB

Flacco has as many playoff wins as Manning and played SEVEN FEWER PLAYOFF GAMES and Manning has been in the NFL TEN YEARS LONGER, with teams that made the playoffs virtually every season.

Ben Roethlisbeger: 10-4, 2-1 in SB
Peyton Manning: 9-11, 1-1 in SB

Looks like Big Ben is the polar opposite of Manning. No flashy numbers, just playoff wins and Super Bowl appearances.

Tom Brady: 17-7
Peyton Manning: 9-11

When it comes to winning, Peyton isn't even in Brady's league.

[slacker00]

How is a guy the "greatest" if he has a losing playoff record, had multiple turnovers in a home playoff game as a big favorite last season, and is 1-1 in Super Bowls with his interception costing them the game at end vs the Saints? The only QB more overrated than Manning was/is Brett Favre.

At least Favre has a winning record in the playoffs. Favre gets a bum rap for hanging on too long and his off field BS.

[PAULYPOKER]

I suppose we'll see, won't we? Let's remember this thread in January!

Ya mean threads like these ones?
Indianapolis makes AFC Playoffs

The Ravens will win the Superbowl

If the Ravens lose the SB I am done posting here!!

Harbaugh Superbowl?

My wildcard round of playoffs plays

[ZOLTAR]

Ya mean threads like these ones?
Indianapolis makes AFC Playoffs

The Ravens will win the Superbowl


If the Ravens lose the SB I am done posting here!!


Harbaugh Superbowl?


My wildcard round of playoffs plays

Those are good, but no big deal. I had New England +400 in their first SuperBowl. Woopee.

[PAULYPOKER]

[slacker00]

My Steelers will save me!!!! ALL IN!!!!!!!!

Pauly lost his wad and then tried to mush the Ravens because his posted plays always lost. lol

[PAULYPOKER]

[Noleafclover]

"As for Manning, he's the best ever because of his level of play."
Playoffs playoffs playoffs we talkin bout playoffs playoffs

I like how you took what I said, and then didn't even respond to it in the slightest and turned it back to your go-to criticism.

[slacker00]

I like how you took what I said, and then didn't even respond to it in the slightest and turned it back to your go-to criticism.

Here are the facts. Peyton is the greatest regular season QB ever. Peyton very average in the playoffs.

[PAULYPOKER]

Here are the facts. Peyton is the greatest regular season QB ever. Peyton very average in the playoffs.

Wow!!

You must have put mountains of research work into that!!!

Great Job!!!

[slacker00]

Wow!!

You must have put mountains of research work into that!!!

Great Job!!!

Yep. I'm trying to boil it down so even you can understand it, PaulyRavens.

[Noleafclover]

Here are the facts. Peyton is the greatest regular season QB ever. Peyton's teams very average in the playoffs.

FTFY. Team game. He isn't the same in the playoffs, though, won't disagree. Average seems pushing it. But still, my point is his level of play overall is the highest there is.

[BriGuy]

Name me all the times Manning choked the most.
Cite games and examples please.

Trailing by 7 in the Super Bowl against New Orleans, taking the ball in the most important drive of his life, he threw a pick-6. In 2003 he had one of his best teams ever and then in the AFCCG threw 4 INT's. Ty Law caught as many Manning passes as Marvin Harrison. And don't even get me started on how he was Steve Spurrier's personal bitch in college. You can't spell "Citrus" without "UT". (and here comes the "it wasn't Manning's fault!" whining)