2012
Record:
SF was 11-4-1
Sea was 11-5 but they were really 10-6 minus that awful final call in the GB game.
Playoffs:
SF lost the SB
SEA lost to Atlanta, probably would have lost wild card to Washington if RG3 didn't blow his knee out.
Division:
SF had a better divisional record but the Rams had the best division record of them all.
Home/away splits:
Seattle is very good at home, had a losing record on the road last year.
SF is very good at home, still a winning record on the road.
Offense/Defense splits:
Seattle scored more points last year and gave up less.
SF had more yards on offense
Both defenses gave up almost the same amount of yards
Seattle forced more turnovers on defense
Seattle offense gave away more turnovers
O-Line
SF has a better offensive line.
QB:
Wilson was a starter for the entire year.
Kaepernick has less starts but he is older. How will these 2 progress?
Kaep looks to have a higher ceiling, stronger arm, better size, better speed, better mid/deep accuracy.
RW knows his role as a game manager. He was efficient last year but averaged under 200 ypg passing.
RW more likely to keep his team in the game, and let you beat yourself. Kaep is more likely to beat you or beat himself.
49ers have a better overall coaching staff, Seattle lost the architect of their defense.
Here is how I see it right now.
Both defenses are very good, 49ers clearly have a better coaching staff, and better O-line which are huge factors. I'd rather trust Russell Wilson at QB right now which is also a huge factor so it's hard to pick. Seattle could go 8-0 at home, but I don't like that they had a losing road record. Their defense probably is "deeper" than the 49ers but SF has more star power in my opinion. Chris Clemons and Cliff Avril are solid pass rushers but not on the same level as Aldon Smith. Justin Smith is better than any Seattle lineman. Bobby Wagner had a fantastic rookie year but he's not Patrick Willis. Sea secondary is better and overall they are both top notch defenses so you have to look at other factors.
QB
Wilson > Kaep
SF O-Line >
SF Coaching >
Defense =
Overall I am leaning more towards SF