Originally Posted by
slacker00
You're right, it's tougher than it looks to do all 32 teams. But, I'm willing to give it a shot.
1. Peyton. He's done it with a whole new team, quite an accomplishment.
2. Brady. It's really 1a and 1b. Brady is having another great year.
3. Ryan. Right now, he's playing great, we'll see what he does in the playoffs.
4. Rogers. Not the same as last year, but he's been missing some key guys.
5. RGIII. The guy is electric and does everything it takes to win.
6. RW. The guy has surged when it matters, in December.
7. Luck. He's put a terrible team on his shoulders and taken them to the playoffs.
8. Kaepernick. Hard to know where to put him, but hard to ignore the potential.
9. Brees. Having a down year, but still top notch, expect a rebound next year.
10. Eli. Coming off his second ring, this year is a bit of a letdown, he'll be back.
11. Ben. Similar to Brees & Eli, a down year, but don't count him out by any means.
12. Schaub. He's somewhat of a caretaker, but does what it takes to win games.
13. Romo. He's good enough to give us hope, but not good enough to deliver.
14. Stafford. He's the poor man's Tony Romo.
15. Newton. Feels like a bit of a sophmore slump, maybe next year will be better.
16. Tannehill. Overshadowed by the other big-3 rookies, but he's also doing great.
17. Freeman. Good numbers, but gets overlooked because the Bucs are a bad team.
18. Dalton. Similar to Freeman except now on a much better team.
19. Cutler. I keep making excuses for Cutler and my patience is wearing thin.
20. Bradford. If he can get more talent around him, he might start to look better.
21. Locker. It's probably too soon to give a final verdict on Locker just yet.
22. Flacco. Maybe the Rodney Dangerfield of QBs.
23. Ponder. Growing pains, working with a hodgepodge of WRs.
24. Vick. Philly is in a tailspin and the QB gets the blame.
25. Fitz. The guy is a backup.
26. Palmer. The sun has set on his career.
27. Gabbert. He's looked like garbage, but maybe next year will be better?
28. Rivers. The guy is capable, but this year is more bust than boom.
29. Cassel. He's a backup calibre guy on a bad team, what do you expect?
30. Weeden. The last of the rookies, there's nowhere to go but up.
31. Sanchez. If he keeps his job, maybe he can have some WRs to throw to next year?
32. Kolb-Skelton-Lindley-Hoyer. Cards will be seeking a QB this offseason.