The top 3 are Manning, Brady, and Palmer IMO. Talent wise, I'd say McNabb is 4th, but in a big game, I'd feel more comfortable with Delhomme back there. Brees is also making a case that he is reaching the upper echelon of QBs as well. But, for me, it's those top 3 and then the rest.
Hard to argue that, owned
I do think that Manning and Brady are SLIGHTLY above Palmer right now and are the only true 'elite' qbs in the NFL.
Palmer is at the top of the 'almost elite' - followed by McNabb and I agree with Delhomme. Good call. I don't think Jake could ever be elite, but I think McNabb could be at times and I think Palmer could, also, with more seasoning.
Jake is what he is.... Elite is not something I think he'll ever get to, even though I love watching him play.
Brees is probably just a touch below the 2nd tier IMO. He can stay in games, but I don't think he's really learned how to win them, yet... And he lacks the 'big play' skill of his peers.
Amazing Brees made a 'sinking ship' stable. Brees has completely changed the way you have to cap the Saints. A stable QB works wonders.
I just question Donovan's decision making during the big games is all. I know Delhomme will never be an "elite" QB, but I feel confident with him QBing the team I'm backing in the 4Qs much more than with McNabb.