[imgv94]

This will be fun.
"PEYTON MANNING"

1.If he retires w/o winning a Superbowl will it make
it impossible to consider him a top 3 QB of all time?

2.Better than Brady?

3.If Tom Brady was the QB for the Colts would they of
won at least one Super Bowl?

4.Say something positive about him?

5.Say something negative about him?

[kalmikrazy]

I think TGO should be let in just to reply to this post......he could prolly write a whole book on those 5 q's imgv.....lol

[bigboydan]

i'd probly think of manning as another marino. "if" he keeps doing what he's doing right now without winning a superbowl.

[imgv94]

I think TGO should be let in just to reply to this post......he could prolly write a whole book on those 5 q's imgv.....lol

TGO is on another site acting crazier than ever.Free
Speech baby!!!

[Razz]

This will be fun.
"PEYTON MANNING"

1.If he retires w/o winning a Superbowl will it make
it impossible to consider him a top 3 QB of all time?

2.Better than Brady?

3.If Tom Brady was the QB for the Colts would they of
won at least one Super Bowl?

4.Say something positive about him?

5.Say something negative about him?

1. No, it won't make it impossible, though I wouldn't consider him one.
2. More talented, but not better.
3. They would have won one.
4. He will win a Super Bowl before his career is over.
5. He has an uncanny knack of throwing for 5 TDs and 400 yards against Arizona and Houston, and getting picked 3 times against the better teams.

Good topic.

[imgv94]

I have a bunch of these Razz.