[goduke]

I'm going to do one for each position but will start with point guards. I just want to see where perception is on this because I remember so many people sucking rondos d.ick over the last couple years who say he sucks now. Or deron williams going to carry the nets as a great point guard when the nets got pierce and garnett. So lets open the discussion for debate and ill check this in the morning. Here are my five in order:

1. Curry
2. Westbrook
3. Parker
4. Lilliard
5. Paul

I'm writing rose off this list because hes a walking injury machine and if you cant put a season together in 2 years then you cant live off your mvp season forever

[smize]

Curry
Westbrook
Rose
Irving
Paul

[Kaboomba]

Not sure why Parker is on there

[goduke]

Not sure why Parker is on there

Just came off a championship, has multiple rings, knows how to lead a team. Not sure why he wouldnt be on there.

[ithinkiamgood]

Goatbrook
Curry
Irving
Paul
Wall

honorable mention - Lillard

[Seto]

1. Westbrook
2. Curry

In no particular order: Irving, Lillard, Paul.

[Catch77]

If Rose can't live off his past then Parker can't either. He is not the same player THIS year as he was in the past. Remove parker and put in Kyle Lowry

[Christopher1991]

People seem to forget defence when ranking point guards.There is no way Paul should be behind curry,the latter is a superior shooter but that is it.

[goduke]

If Rose can't live off his past then Parker can't either. He is not the same player THIS year as he was in the past. Remove parker and put in Kyle Lowry

Rose has had one year 2 years ago, parker has a championship just last year. Big difference. Im not looking at who puts up huge numbers, theres more to a point guard then just that

[Conqueror]

Ancient Paul
Wildbrook
Chicken Curry
Irving
Lillard

[GoBlue77]

Lillard has to be ranked higher than Wall on whatever list. Wall CANT shoot.

Westbrook
Curry
Uncle Drew

than whoever...

[KRIT]

The top 4 are a no brainer (in no order):

Curry
Paul
Westbrook
Lillard

You can argue about #5 between Irving, Wall, Rose, Lowry, Conley. I'd probably give the nod to Irving but tough to say.

[Seto]

Lillard has to be ranked higher than Wall on whatever list. Wall CANT shoot.

Westbrook
Curry
Uncle Drew

than whoever...

I wouldn't even put Wall in the top 10. Dude is so so overrated. Utterly useless in the halfcourt.

[MoMoneyMoVaughn]

If Rose can't live off his past then Parker can't either. He is not the same player THIS year as he was in the past. Remove parker and put in Kyle Lowry

No NO NO!

[IllyPhilly[DOC]]

WHY HAVE I NOT SEEN JAMES MOFO HARDEN mentioned???

[IllyPhilly[DOC]]

WHY HAVE I NOT SEEN JAMES MOFO HARDEN mentioned???

He has been the leading scorer all year before W.B. had 10.5 triple doubles in 1 week.

[smize]

Duhhh because his postition is wing?

[goldengreek]

WHY HAVE I NOT SEEN JAMES MOFO HARDEN mentioned???

[IllyPhilly[DOC]]

Duhhh because his postition is wing?

His wing position averages 7 assists a game. The most on his team....

[smize]

Ok I thought we were talking point guards??? LOL

[Seto]

His wing position averages 7 assists a game. The most on his team....

So then LeBron should be in this conversation too right? And while we're at it passing bigs too - Gasol, Noah, Griffin?

[IllyPhilly[DOC]]

So then LeBron should be in this conversation too right? And while we're at it passing bigs too - Gasol, Noah, Griffin?

Well no cuz Lebron is a forward not a guard. See Harden plays the guard position and 90% of every possession runs through his hands. I like ya'll think I'm crazy for mention Harden. How is he not arguably the best PG for his TEAM...

[Seto]

Well no cuz Lebron is a forward not a guard. See Harden plays the guard position and 90% of every possession runs through his hands. I like ya'll think I'm crazy for mention Harden. How is he not arguably the best PG for his TEAM...

So a shooting guard who has the ball in his hands most of the time is a PG in your book (Harden) but a small forward who does the exact same thing (LeBron) doesn't fit the bill? Makes zero sense. Do you consider Kobe to be a point guard too? How about D Wade?

If your argument is that NBA is positionless these days fine, but then you have to put LeBron in the discussion too.

[smize]

Yup LeBron is #1 then . Cause I see him bringing the ball down the court 90% of the time too. Yup. Lolol

No but for real though if your looking at it like that then Kobe and Paul George have to be in the top 5.

[SharkAA]

Westbrook
Curry
Paul
Parker
Lillard

[IllyPhilly[DOC]]

So a shooting guard who has the ball in his hands most of the time is a PG in your book (Harden) but a small forward who does the exact same thing (LeBron) doesn't fit the bill? Makes zero sense. Do you consider Kobe to be a point guard too? How about D Wade?

If your argument is that NBA is positionless these days fine, but then you have to put LeBron in the discussion too.

Why can't I make that argument? HE is a freak of nature. No one else in the NBA does what Harden does for his team. How many shooting guards play this game? He has developed into this player for HOU who doesn't need a PG because they have HARDEN. Here what I'm trying to say? Yall are trying to play me and be smart and mention other FORWARDS... BUT it really isnt the same. LETS be honest HARDEN should be mentioned because no one else does what he does! Okay I can see the Lebron angle maybe, but really your mentioning him to mock what I'm trying to argue.

[IllyPhilly[DOC]]

LIke cmon fellas out of the 5 most mentioned in W.B.+Lillard+Curry+Paul+Parker, I would take Harden over all of them. Wait... Curry or Harden.

[upscope]

Philly, please stop!!

[upscope]

Not in top 5 but T. Evans has been balling minus Jrue

[smize]

Philly why not Paul George then? He's going to dominate when he comes back very soon

nd he plays guard too like harden