I know it seems like a long shot at first, but I'm taking Leafs TT o2.5 -115
Leafs are a team that's scores on the road. They are 18-10 going o2.5 goals on the road this season. They just scored 7 goals last night. So, yes they could be tired tonight. But there's also a chance they are just hot shooting the puck right now.
Sergei Bobrovsky isn't in net for Columbus. Joonas Korpisalo is tonight. When I started this post, I assumed Sergei was playing tonight. Now I'm surprised odds are only -115.