I apologize in advance if this is a dumb question..........
So last night I was doing my standard procedure of shopping lines for the bowl game hoping to find some arbitrage/middle opportunities. A local had Southern Miss +3, and Matchbook had Louisville -2.5 (+104) or Louisville -3 (+120).
I locked in $550 to win $500 with the local, and was trying to determine the highest EV between my two Louisville options. Really the only question I am asking here, is how do I determine the probability that Louisville is going to win by exactly 3. Using a push chart I determined 6%, but is that correct? Or is it a 3% chance that Lousville wins by 3 and a 3% chance that Southern Miss wins by 3? Like I said, stupid question but something is not clicking for me.
Anyway, using 6% push rate I came to the following numbers.......
Betting the -2.5 line, 6% push rate, I came to an ROI of 1.6%.
Betting the -3 line, 6% push rate, I came to an ROI of 2.1%.
So based on my calculation, and with the total as high as 60, and with my insecurity as to whether I should even be using a push rate as high as 6%, I convinced myself that taking the Lousivlle -3 line was my smartest investment, which obviously failed miserably for me.
I took the -3 because my EV calculation told me that had a higher return. Because of the push I actually had to pay $50 to my local and I ended uo losing money. Extremely disappointing evening.