1. #1
    davidsiegel
    davidsiegel's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-07-13
    Posts: 5

    A quick research question/quiz

    Dear members,

    I run a workshop for business decisionmakers on cognitive biases and statistical decisionmaking. I'd like to ask a research question here. Just answer yes or no in the reply box:

    I have a bag with 9 white marbles and 1 black marble. If you give me $100, I will let you draw one marble out of the bag. If it's white, i keep your money. If it's black, I will give you $1400.


    Assuming you can afford to lose $100 but that this is real money and you value it, and that you can't do it a second time: do you take this bet?

  2. #2
    Conan
    Conan's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 09-01-10
    Posts: 1,178
    Betpoints: 818

    yes

  3. #3
    matthew919
    Update your status
    matthew919's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 11-21-12
    Posts: 421
    Betpoints: 5869

    If we are allowed to repeat this exact scenario (say on the order of 100 times), then yes.
    If this a one time bet only, and no other wager opportunities exist in the known universe- then no.

    I ain't made-a-money.

  4. #4
    tto827
    tto827's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 10-01-12
    Posts: 9,078
    Betpoints: 76

    Yes

  5. #5
    yak merchant
    yak merchant's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 11-04-10
    Posts: 109
    Betpoints: 6170

    Actually no. Not because the math doesn't work, but because it works too well. I'm pretty sure if you are offering such an awesome deal, you are going to backdoor me. I'm sure you will find a way to tell me I cheated when I do win. 9 times out of ten that doesn't happen and I think I got a fair shake, but if it does, you are going to f... me. I'd consider it if your 1400 was sitting on the table next to my 100 and I'm the only one with a pistol in the room.
    Points Awarded:

    chopperocker gave yak merchant 2 SBR Point(s) for this post.


  6. #6
    buby74
    buby74's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 06-08-10
    Posts: 92
    Betpoints: 21207

    Only if my bankroll is more than $3250 (kelly criterion). The fact this bet won't be repeated is irrelevant as I will have other +ev opportunities in the future .

  7. #7
    davidsiegel
    davidsiegel's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-07-13
    Posts: 5

    Thanks for the responses. Obviously, this is a research question, not real life. You can assume that the money goes on the table and that you have as much money as you have right now. It's not a gambling session mixed in with others. It's a one-time offer from a stranger who's willing to pony up the cash. Anyone else? I'd love to get dozens of responses and see what people say.

  8. #8
    EXhoosier10
    EXhoosier10's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-06-09
    Posts: 3,122
    Betpoints: 4390

    yes

  9. #9
    u21c3f6
    u21c3f6's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 01-17-09
    Posts: 790
    Betpoints: 5198

    No. Even though the wager is +EV, the one-shot deal makes it gambling to me.

    Joe.

  10. #10
    James D
    James D's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 01-03-13
    Posts: 2,040

    I "value the money" is a very vague statement. It would depend on how much I had of course. However from your explanation I would say NO​.

  11. #11
    Bosseman22
    Bosseman22's Avatar SBR PRO
    Join Date: 09-30-09
    Posts: 286
    Betpoints: 43540

    no don't like games of chance

  12. #12
    snapperman2
    Keep bothering on
    snapperman2's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 08-19-10
    Posts: 2,078
    Betpoints: 16306

    yes

  13. #13
    Kolotoure
    Kolotoure's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 01-28-12
    Posts: 28
    Betpoints: 654

    Seems like it hinges on the value/utility $100 has to each individual person

  14. #14
    statnerds
    Put me in coach
    statnerds's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 09-23-09
    Posts: 4,047
    Betpoints: 103

    yes

  15. #15
    EXhoosier10
    EXhoosier10's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-06-09
    Posts: 3,122
    Betpoints: 4390

    Quote Originally Posted by Kolotoure View Post
    Seems like it hinges on the value/utility $100 has to each individual person
    this was my thinking at first, but then he said that you could afford to lose $100. Why the F not, at that point

  16. #16
    u21c3f6
    u21c3f6's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 01-17-09
    Posts: 790
    Betpoints: 5198

    Quote Originally Posted by EXhoosier10 View Post
    this was my thinking at first, but then he said that you could afford to lose $100. Why the F not, at that point
    Because I don't like to lose! When I look for an edge, I also look at what is my expectation of showing a profit. Since this is only a one-shot deal with only a small chance of being profitable, I would pass.

    Joe.

  17. #17
    Conan
    Conan's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 09-01-10
    Posts: 1,178
    Betpoints: 818

    Quote Originally Posted by u21c3f6 View Post
    Because I don't like to lose! When I look for an edge, I also look at what is my expectation of showing a profit. Since this is only a one-shot deal with only a small chance of being profitable, I would pass.

    Joe.
    Its the same with all sports lines all blackjack mach bet deals and what not. Each individual line you bet because you feel you have the edge is a one shot deal. There is no way that exact game will ever happen again there is no guarantee you will find a another game tomorrow where you think the line is favorable. No guarantee the FBI wont shut down your book and you wont be able to wager. The point here is you have an edge here, assuming the proper bankroll issues witch have bean discussed above, your either the kind of person who jumps on +EV opportunities or you are not.

  18. #18
    Teamprofit101
    Gmail
    Teamprofit101's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 12-14-11
    Posts: 336

    How can this be +EV if you only get one shot?

  19. #19
    Conan
    Conan's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 09-01-10
    Posts: 1,178
    Betpoints: 818

    Quote Originally Posted by Teamprofit101 View Post
    How can this be +EV if you only get one shot?
    the same way a mach play at BJ is +EV with only one shot if this was the only game you ever played you have i 9 in 10 shot of dropping 100 and a 1 in 10 shot of making 1400 but if you always take these positive opportunities even though this one is only available once others will become available down the line.

  20. #20
    BuddyBear
    Update your status
    BuddyBear's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 08-10-05
    Posts: 7,233
    Betpoints: 4805

    Yes. Absolutely. See Kahnamen and Tversky's (1979) prospect theory for further explanation.

  21. #21
    brettd
    brettd's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 01-25-10
    Posts: 229
    Betpoints: 3869

    Quote Originally Posted by davidsiegel View Post
    Dear members,

    I run a workshop for business decisionmakers on cognitive biases and statistical decisionmaking. I'd like to ask a research question here. Just answer yes or no in the reply box:

    I have a bag with 9 white marbles and 1 black marble. If you give me $100, I will let you draw one marble out of the bag. If it's white, i keep your money. If it's black, I will give you $1400.


    Assuming you can afford to lose $100 but that this is real money and you value it, and that you can't do it a second time: do you take this bet?
    From an +EV perspective, of course.

    This comes down to whether you have enough capital to take this opportunity without having the investment become -EG to your bankroll/capital/assets etc.

  22. #22
    James D
    James D's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 01-03-13
    Posts: 2,040

    Quote Originally Posted by Teamprofit101 View Post
    How can this be +EV if you only get one shot?

    It is +EV for sure regardless of how many shots you get, one or ten thousand. You are getting 13-1 on your bet and the odds of winning are 9-1. That it is +EV is not in dispute from a pure mathematical standpoint.

    Your personal circumstance is what decides whether you should make the bet. Let me give you 2 extremes that are just more extreme examples of the question at hand.

    1. You are a gambler and you only get one shot at the example posted above for 100 dollars. Odds are as described, 9-1 shot to win 13-1. You are a very successful gambler with millions at your disposal to gamble. This decision is very easy the answer is YES

    2. You are not a gambler and have a net worth of 220k I offer you a similar chance only with 999 black marbles and only 1 winning white marble. The bet is for 200k if you defy the odds and pick the winning marble you will be paid 210 million dollars. Now from a strictly statistical point of view this is a good bet. The odds of winning are 999-1 so the payout should only be 200 million dollars (999-1) however I am paying you 210 million dollars. So the payout is actually 1049-1. However only a fool would risk virtually everything they have on a one time 999-1 shot. In this case even though the math says yes the answer is a RESOUNDING NO.



  23. #23
    dbear808
    dbear808's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-16-11
    Posts: 36
    Betpoints: 1067

    Anytime you have a gambling proposition that is +EV, you must take advantage of it. As stated in the proposition by the OP, this is a pure gambling opportunity. There are no excuses related to your financial situation that would preclude you from gambling in this situation. My answer to the question is YES.

  24. #24
    James D
    James D's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 01-03-13
    Posts: 2,040

    Quote Originally Posted by dbear808 View Post
    Anytime you have a gambling proposition that is +EV, you must take advantage of it. As stated in the proposition by the OP, this is a pure gambling opportunity. There are no excuses related to your financial situation that would preclude you from gambling in this situation. .
    Not true.

    So if your entire net worth is 500k and I offer to flip a coin and will pay you 501k if you win but take your 500k if you lose then you would agree to the flip?

  25. #25
    Conan
    Conan's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 09-01-10
    Posts: 1,178
    Betpoints: 818

    Quote Originally Posted by dbear808 View Post
    Anytime you have a gambling proposition that is +EV, you must take advantage of it. As stated in the proposition by the OP, this is a pure gambling opportunity. There are no excuses related to your financial situation that would preclude you from gambling in this situation. My answer to the question is YES.
    You need to understand bankroll witch was attempted to be clarified by the question but he wasn't apparently coverd completely.

  26. #26
    dbear808
    dbear808's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-16-11
    Posts: 36
    Betpoints: 1067

    I am not going to waste my time and energy responding to something that is obvious. The Op asked a question with set parameters. In that vacuum, the answer is yes.

  27. #27
    James D
    James D's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 01-03-13
    Posts: 2,040

    Quote Originally Posted by dbear808 View Post
    Anytime you have a gambling proposition that is +EV, you must take advantage of it. As stated in the proposition by the OP, this is a pure gambling opportunity. There are no excuses related to your financial situation that would preclude you from gambling in this situation. My answer to the question is YES.

    Whether you decide to "waste your time and energy responding doesn't make a difference. This post of your is 100% wrong.
    That is what is 100% obvious.

  28. #28
    Miz
    Miz's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 08-30-09
    Posts: 693
    Betpoints: 3132

    Quote Originally Posted by buby74 View Post
    Only if my bankroll is more than $3250 (kelly criterion). The fact this bet won't be repeated is irrelevant as I will have other +ev opportunities in the future .
    This... and...

    The poster that assumed shenanigans would take place is also wise to be suspicious of such a "too good to be true" offer.

  29. #29
    ClimbSomeRocks
    ClimbSomeRocks's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 11-04-09
    Posts: 1,081
    Betpoints: 259

    yes. It's like reverse gambling. The payout is in your favor and this should be taken advantage of as well as any other future +EV wagers

  30. #30
    McFly86
    McFly86's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 01-15-11
    Posts: 149
    Betpoints: 1971

    Amusing how so many people ignore the info about "if you can afford to lose the $100". YES YOU PLAY THIS GAME

  31. #31
    runnershane14
    runnershane14's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-23-07
    Posts: 803
    Betpoints: 84

    yes

  32. #32
    gojetsgomoxies
    gojetsgomoxies's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 09-04-12
    Posts: 4,222
    Betpoints: 8519

    obviously completely related to risk-aversion.

    obvious yes to me unless i'm worried about cheating.

    of course, if it was $100K at the same odds alot more people have to think about it, especially if you have to borrow some of the money.

    most people wouldn't do $100K at slight +EV. but $100 no problem for most people at your very generous EV.

  33. #33
    NunyaBidness
    NunyaBidness has a posse
    NunyaBidness's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-26-09
    Posts: 9,345
    Betpoints: 4507

    How the penetrate is this retarded shit in the think tank?

    There is no discussion to be had here. If your response to this question is anything other than "why the hell do you have to ask" then you really shouldn't be gambling.

  34. #34
    NunyaBidness
    NunyaBidness has a posse
    NunyaBidness's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 07-26-09
    Posts: 9,345
    Betpoints: 4507

    Quote Originally Posted by Teamprofit101 View Post
    How can this be +EV if you only get one shot?
    Nomination(s):
    This post was nominated 1 time . To view the nominated thread please click here. People who nominated: tto827

  35. #35
    Teamprofit101
    Gmail
    Teamprofit101's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 12-14-11
    Posts: 336

    Quote Originally Posted by NunyaBidness View Post
    Thank you

    If i can give you points I would for being the most helpful ass of the day.

12 Last
Top