[Marigold HD]

Who has a better year??

[Marigold HD]

I'm going to add Colston to the list.

I'm guessing the order with be

1. Bowe
2. Colston
3. Amendola
4. Garcon

[Monitor-Tan]

Garcon
Colston
Bowe
Amendola

would be my guess

[Speedy88]

Assuming they all play 16 games, I think Amendola would be the best choice. I'd probably rank it as:

Amendola, Colston, Garcon, Bowe.

Very close though. Only thing that worries me about Bowe is that Alex Smith doesn't like to throw to the outside.

[Cross]

Colston, Amendola, Bowe, Garçon.

[Wrigley]

Bowe
Colston
Garcon
Amendola

[Wrigley]

I think Alex Smith in the Andy Reid offense will do wonders for Bowe

[Marigold HD]

wow....I think I will stick with Colston since he is in everyone's top 2

[downsouth]

IF its PPR I'd rate whichever out of Garcon and Amendola can stay healthy first, Colston Third, and Bowe fourth. In my opinion though Colston is probably the safest but I believe even he is fighting a few nagging injuries lately.

[CMNoney]

PPR Amendola and it's not close. If he stays healthy he is a lock to catch 100+ balls.

[Andy117]

PPR Amendola and it's not close. If he stays healthy he is a lock to catch 100+ balls.

He's never stayed healthy. I'll take Bowe.

[Marigold HD]

It's not a PPR.......

[downsouth]

It's not a PPR.......

Then yeah, I probably take Colston first. Bowe probably has the most upside of that group though in non-PPR but he will also have weeks where he is invisible.

[Grits n' Gravy]

3 of the 4 are "injury prone". I'd take Amendola or Garçon.

[Ghenghis Kahn]

amendola is injury prone.

i'd go with either bowe or garcon.

oops forgot about colston. he's not 100%. not sure he'll have a productive year this year.

[Terrapin Station]

I think Garcon is going to have one hell of a season. If he stays on the field, Amendola should have a ton of passes thrown his way too.