Originally Posted by
Ladle
You're forgetting Lyoto Machida (incidentally, the shots which Machida messed Franklin up with weren't particularly brutal). And, as I said, Franklin was rocked and dropped by weak punches from Evan Tanner and David Loiseau. He does not have a good chin. It's as simple as that.
The Machida fight was in 2003 - both guys were different fighters. Mahida dropped Rampage too, doesnt mean Rampage has a weak chin.
The point still stands that if he tags Franklin with a decent punch, Franklin is probably going to get rocked. And as we've seen from Rich Franklin several times before, upon getting rocked, he does not recover well.
Does not recover well? He got up and finished both Tanner and the Crow. Yea he didn't recover from Anderson Silva and Belfort, but pretty much no one does. He took a bomb from henderson in Round 1, and recovered well. Keep in mind that just b/c you get dropped it doesnt mean the fight is over or u have a weak chin....or else Faber would have won that fight against Cruz based on 3 knockdowns.
Definitely disagree. You can't intelligently say that Franklin has a better chance of knocking out Rogerio than vice versa. Franklin might have better movement and a more diverse striking game, but his chin sucks. Rogerio is a better technical boxer, can take a decent lick, and has more than enough power to hurt, drop, and possibly finish Franklin.
Once again, his chin does not "suck." As i said, Rich has only been finished by two guys in the past 7 years. He's been dropped, but always recovered and won the fight. He also took a few hard shots from Wandy, and ended up winning a very decisive decision. Rampage got knocked down by Shogun, Wandy, Dan hendo, and Machida....dont mean hes got a weak chin. He got Ko'ed twice, but actually recovered to win against hendo and machida.
Also, Franklin has just a good chance of dropping Rogerio as Rogerio can drop Franklin. Franklin has many more stoppages than Rogerio....so lets not think narrowly and assume only Rogerio can threaten Franklin and not vice versa. If Franklin tags Rogerio w/ a good shot, its likely Rogerio is going to stumble as well.
Rogerio should definitely be favoured. He's easily a good enough boxer to put Franklin in a lot of trouble on the feet. If Loiseau and Tanner can hurt Franklin, then so can Rogerio.