1. #1
    thegreatdiatchi
    thegreatdiatchi's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 03-07-08
    Posts: 1,154

    Is Johan Santana still the best pitcher in baseball?

    Last season he was shaky the whole first half and now he's off to the same kind of start this year. Don't get me wrong, I still consider him one of the top pitchers in the league & would love to have him on my fantasy team but do you think there are some other pitchers (Peavy, Webb) who deserve #1 consideration?

  2. #2
    St. Andrew
    St. Andrew's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-23-08
    Posts: 2,265

    The best pitcher in baseball is Jake Peavy.

  3. #3
    austintx05
    austintx05's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 08-24-06
    Posts: 3,156

    of course he is. His entire career he has been a 2nd half pitcher, but most expect him to win every time especially now with the type of money he got in New York.

    Sorry, Peavy's stuff isn't as good as Santana. I would take Halladay over Peavy any day...

  4. #4
    austintx05
    austintx05's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 08-24-06
    Posts: 3,156

    Quote Originally Posted by St. Andrew View Post
    The best pitcher in baseball is Jake Peavy.
    false

  5. #5
    St. Andrew
    St. Andrew's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-23-08
    Posts: 2,265

    Quote Originally Posted by austintx05 View Post
    I would take Halladay over Peavy any day...
    Really?

    2007:

    Halladay 3.71 ERA, 139 K's, 232 hits in 225 innings
    Peavy 2.54 ERA, 240 K's, 169 hits in 223 innings

    Don't ever type nonsense such as that again.

  6. #6
    ryanXL977
    ryanXL977's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-24-08
    Posts: 20,615

    peavy is better than halladay

    johan
    peavy

    top 2 by a mile

    best big game pitcher"? beckett. peavy is not the man when it comes to playoffs

  7. #7
    AgainstAllOdds
    From the Villas to world #1
    AgainstAllOdds's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-24-08
    Posts: 6,053

    cheng-ming wang

  8. #8
    ryanXL977
    ryanXL977's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-24-08
    Posts: 20,615

    wang is not CLOSE to those other guys
    he is good but he isnt even as good as webb
    nobody is scraed of wang the way they fear peavy and johan

    come on now

  9. #9
    moneyline
    moneyline's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 01-18-08
    Posts: 1,748

    All Wang does is wins, but in today's (gotta see some K's world of fantasy baseball) he is overlooked.

    19-6
    19-7
    3-0

    Yep. 41-13 works just fine for me. How 'bout you?

  10. #10
    stump
    stump's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 09-14-05
    Posts: 1,715
    Betpoints: 108

    nope, he hasn't been for the last 1 1/2 yrs

  11. #11
    ryanXL977
    ryanXL977's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-24-08
    Posts: 20,615

    i know wang is good
    but he is not as good as those other
    compare run support also

  12. #12
    imgv94
    imgv94's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 11-16-05
    Posts: 17,192
    Betpoints: 10

    Peavy

  13. #13
    onlooker
    I'm still watching...
    onlooker's Avatar SBR PRO
    Join Date: 08-10-05
    Posts: 36,572
    Betpoints: 4651

    You can't go wrong with either Peavy or Santana. I would say Peavy because he has the advantages of PETCO.

  14. #14
    austintx05
    austintx05's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 08-24-06
    Posts: 3,156

    I don't care about era, cause its useless. Peavy does have a major advantage in Petco, but I don't cut Halladay any slack. While he may not strikeout as many batters, he knows the art of pitching, which is lost in today's baseball.

  15. #15
    austintx05
    austintx05's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 08-24-06
    Posts: 3,156

    Quote Originally Posted by St. Andrew View Post
    Really?

    2007:

    Halladay 3.71 ERA, 139 K's, 232 hits in 225 innings
    Peavy 2.54 ERA, 240 K's, 169 hits in 223 innings

    Don't ever type nonsense such as that again.
    both great pitchers. Just cause we don't agree doesn't mean my opinion is nonsense. Look at Peavy's 2006 season posting a 4.06 era. IMO, Doc has been pitching longer vs better lineups longer. There was a time where Doc was not so hot until he changed his delivery.

  16. #16
    TheLock
    TheLock's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 04-06-08
    Posts: 14,429
    Betpoints: 7931

    Peavy

  17. #17
    eidolon
    USA
    eidolon's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 01-02-08
    Posts: 9,531
    Betpoints: 15766

    SP
    Santana
    Peavy
    Hamels
    Smoltz
    cueto

    RP
    Papelbon
    Saito
    Chamberlain
    K-Rod
    Wagner

  18. #18
    moneyline
    moneyline's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 01-18-08
    Posts: 1,748

    Santana will not win over 16 games this year. Wanna bet?

  19. #19
    ryanXL977
    ryanXL977's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-24-08
    Posts: 20,615

    did someone just put cueto in the top 5?

    thats funny

  20. #20
    austintx05
    austintx05's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 08-24-06
    Posts: 3,156


  21. #21
    MJFtheGenius
    MODERATOR
    MJFtheGenius's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 05-31-07
    Posts: 7,257
    Betpoints: 1176

    Peavy is definetly not the best pitcher in baseball.
    He pitches in the national league it's like AA ball.

    Johan does not have the same stuff anymore, there is a reason the Twins let him go. They are one of the best run team in baseball.

    Halliday,beckett, wang, Sabathia, are all better then both of those guys. However even how weak the national league is I still think brandon Webb is the best pitcher and has the best stuff.

  22. #22
    ryanXL977
    ryanXL977's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-24-08
    Posts: 20,615

    johan doesnt have the same stuff? the twins let he and hunter go because they odnt have money, not bc he doesnthave the same stuff
    he has the exact stuff.

    wang is not better than danny haren, or lackey, i can name a lot of dudes better than wang

    johan s the best
    every yr

  23. #23
    austintx05
    austintx05's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 08-24-06
    Posts: 3,156

    this thread shows me how many idiots watch baseball.

    lackey? are you ****ing serious? He has one good year...gimme a break.

    Wang has more wins last 2 years than all of them

  24. #24
    MJFtheGenius
    MODERATOR
    MJFtheGenius's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 05-31-07
    Posts: 7,257
    Betpoints: 1176

    austin makes a good point.

    Same story with haren, lets not crown his ass right away.

  25. #25
    MJFtheGenius
    MODERATOR
    MJFtheGenius's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 05-31-07
    Posts: 7,257
    Betpoints: 1176

    Quote Originally Posted by ryanXL977 View Post
    johan doesnt have the same stuff? the twins let he and hunter go because they odnt have money, not bc he doesnthave the same stuff
    he has the exact stuff.

    wang is not better than danny haren, or lackey, i can name a lot of dudes better than wang

    johan s the best
    every yr

    Not true my friend. Get your facts straight next time you come to the table. They did have the money and they chose to spend it on Joe Nathan instead. They had other options at closer but still took nathan over Santana who has been the face of the pitching staff for years. I'm just saying I belive the twins think he is not as dominent for whatever reason anymore. It's early lets give Johan some more time.

  26. #26
    ryanXL977
    ryanXL977's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-24-08
    Posts: 20,615

    lackey has one good year eh? yeah, you watch a lot of baseball.

  27. #27
    MJFtheGenius
    MODERATOR
    MJFtheGenius's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 05-31-07
    Posts: 7,257
    Betpoints: 1176

    Lackey and Wang are at the same level.

  28. #28
    ryanXL977
    ryanXL977's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-24-08
    Posts: 20,615

    that may be true
    but haren is better
    so is carmona

  29. #29
    MJFtheGenius
    MODERATOR
    MJFtheGenius's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 05-31-07
    Posts: 7,257
    Betpoints: 1176

    Carmona and Haren in no way deserve to be better then Wang.

  30. #30
    MJFtheGenius
    MODERATOR
    MJFtheGenius's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 05-31-07
    Posts: 7,257
    Betpoints: 1176

    Carmona has never even led a pitching staff.

  31. #31
    ryanXL977
    ryanXL977's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-24-08
    Posts: 20,615

    carmona sure had a nice yr last yr didnt he? wang is a good solid pitcher, his stuff isnt close to carmonas
    not close

  32. #32
    ryanXL977
    ryanXL977's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 02-24-08
    Posts: 20,615

    wang isnt better than penny, he isnt better than webb
    he gets wins, he gets run support, he ks nobody
    he is solid, if he werent a yankee nobody would evercome close to naming him in the top tier
    he is not top 10

  33. #33
    MJFtheGenius
    MODERATOR
    MJFtheGenius's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 05-31-07
    Posts: 7,257
    Betpoints: 1176

    It was carmona first year pitching full time buddy. Let's see what happens this year when the hitters get more use to his stuff. I'm not saying he will have a bad year I am saying let's see. Wang has had 3 solid seasons now.

  34. #34
    MJFtheGenius
    MODERATOR
    MJFtheGenius's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 05-31-07
    Posts: 7,257
    Betpoints: 1176

    penny is a head case. i would not want him pitching for my team. No way he could cut in the American league.

  35. #35
    austintx05
    austintx05's Avatar Become A Pro!
    Join Date: 08-24-06
    Posts: 3,156

    Quote Originally Posted by ryanXL977 View Post
    lackey has one good year eh? yeah, you watch a lot of baseball.
    i am the most knowledgeable person on baseball at this forum.

    Last year was Lackey's best year by far. First time he posted 19 wins and while his career era is flirting with 4.00 he posted a 3.01 era last season. My point it I wouldn't expect another season from Lackey like last year.

    Same thing goes for Carmona and CC. Carmona was a horrible bullpen pitcher and then he has a great year. Obviously mechanics changed, but lets see how he does this season, especially with the money they just threw at him.

1234 ... Last
Top