My two cents.
It's not that bad of a bet.
Having said that it's hardly play of the year material.
Crap, it's not even play of the day material.
You can make a case for both sides of the coin.
Why it's a decent play.
Cleveland is a very, very good offensive team versus left handed pitching.
MLB rankings versus LHP
#2 in runs scored, #4 in OBA, pretty much top five in the majors across the board versus LHP. Except home runs.
They don't hit many homers off of LHP, they score all those runs by stringing baserunners together, and there in lies the problem.
The lefty they have to face is Chris Sale, and you just don't get many oppurtunities in a nine inning game to get many baserunners on off of Sale.
It doesn't matter if you got it from the horses mouth or not that Carrasco is in for a bad outing, history shows the top of the White Sox order has never had a problem with Carrasco in the past, especially Melke, and Adam Eaton drives him nuts too.
However both of them are Punch and Judy hitters, they are scrappy hitters that do not hit for power.
Take away Abreu and the whole White Sox team doesn't hit for much power.
What I am trying to say here is 7 runs total (I know the iine is 6.5, but you need 7 to win) in this game is doable, however don't count on the long ball to get you there, for this total to hit, you are going to need the Indians to string 3 runs off of Sale and the White Sox to get four from Carrasco.
If Carrasco does get pulled, the Indians have a very tidy bullpen. Not lock down, but top 8 in the majors.
And know this, Chris Sale never rolls over, he's a son of a bitch bulldog that gives a shit, gives a shit on every pitch.
And even though White Sox pen is leaky, Sale usually goes deep into games.
One final though, since Mike Muchlinski umpired first base last night he rotates to behind the plate and gets to call the balls and strikes.
He has umpired home 16 games this year, and the unders have covered 7 times and the overs have covered nine times.
The good news is the average number of total runs scored when Muchinski umps is 7.1
http://www.statfox.com/mlb/umpire.as...KE&season=2015
If you like the over, consider White Sox over 3 runs as well.
Best of luck.