Originally Posted by
Mr Handicapable
Morris has been just as important to the Skins as RG3. To put any of the rookie kids ahead of Eli and Brees is ridiculous at this point.
1. Rodgers.....can carry a team better than anyone. Jennings/Jordy Nelson missed alot of games and their D isn't that great either
2. Brady.....interchangeable w/PM but arm is stronger which might help more in Jan. Both are HOFers and as smart as it gets.
3. P Manning.....weaker arm in Jan. cold/wind concerns me but has had another MVP type year
4. Ryan....no playoff excuses this year with #1 seed and solid D behind him
5. Eli....nobody repeats anymore....Nicks needs to be 100%
6. Luck...best of the kids imo.....has to carry the team and has while taking a beating
7. Brees....still one of the best....prob still top 3 if he didn't have to force the ball in shoot outs every week
8. RG3.....great ability....little skinny though to run the ball this much and he hasn't had to throw it that much with Morris
9. Big Ben.....bad year this year.....about to fall out for good imo due to so many hits taking their toll
10. Dalton....always underrated....they don't run that well so he (& AJ Green) have to do it by themselves usually
11. Kaepernick.....great great talent but who knows if these RG3 type read option guys can get hit that much and play every week. Can he be a pocket guy if need be?
12. Russell Wilson.....smart smart kid and great leader but Lynch sets up everything
here's my dirty dozen....ok I did put Luck ahead of some of the vets...thats because of how much he carries Indy. AL must get hit hard 30x/game with that line and still produces.