Originally Posted by
irish1
Hey unusailsusp5, are there any pitchers right now currently playing who can win 20 or more 4 straight years? The best pitchers currently are Justin Verlander, Max Scherzer, Clayton Kershaw and Felix Hernandez. None of them have won 20 games 4 times in a row and probably never will. They have won 20 but to do it 4 consecutive seasons is quite another thing. Cuellar and McNally pitched in an era with some teriffic players and that feat has them hall of fame worthy to me. Cuellar was 20 three times in a row then 18,18, and another 20 win season. McNally was 4 straight. Would you say they were dominant in their 13 years ? Is the hall of fame about dominance? Were they two of the best pitchers in their time?