Don't overthink this one. Tigers offense will not be shut down by this clown. Scherzer has had trouble on the road but is LITERALLY 10 times better than Garcia so this is a no-brainer for me. Fister and Nova both looked great last night, with a lot of life on all their pitches and you'll see the same with Scherzer. However, Garcia throws that straight BP, and I just don't see a pitcher like that shutting down either of these offenses.
I don't think Fister was awful. He just made 3 or 4 awful pitches and you can't do that against yanks. Man I hope they can hang on here. Max looks great so far!